In this article
  1. What You’re Probably Picturing
  2. What Actually Happens After the Implants Come Out
  3. Less Is More
  4. Why I Usually Don’t Add a Lift
  5. Why Fat Grafting at the Same Time Rarely Helps
  6. What Happens to the Capsule
  7. Recovery
  8. If You Do Want More Later
  9. Frequently Asked Questions

Almost every woman who comes to me to have her implants removed asks the same question, in one form or another: “What am I going to look like?” Usually she already has a picture in her mind, and it isn’t a good one.

The honest answer is that the breasts will look deflated at first. And in almost every case, once they heal, they look significantly better than she expected. That’s been my experience with hundreds of women, and it shapes how I plan the operation.

What You’re Probably Picturing

The image most women describe is two empty bags of skin, or two empty socks. It’s an understandable fear. The implant has been stretching the skin and the breast tissue for years, sometimes decades, and it seems logical that taking it out would leave all of that stretched skin hanging with nothing inside.

The internet doesn’t help. The photos that get shared are often taken in the first days or weeks after surgery, before the breast has had any chance to recover. They show a real stage of healing, but not where it ends up.

What Actually Happens After the Implants Come Out

Right after surgery the breasts look deflated. That part is true. But skin and breast tissue aren’t a fixed bag. Once the implant is gone, the skin starts to tighten and the breast tissue, which has been compressed and thinned by the implant, starts to thicken again as it heals. The breasts look better week by week, and they keep improving for months.

FOLDSKINCONTRACTSTISSUETHICKENSWEEK 16 WEEKS3 MONTHS6 MONTHSSIDE VIEW
How the breast changes as it heals, seen from the side. About a week after the implants come out, the skin is loose and the breast tissue is thin, so the breast looks deflated and sits a little low. Over three to six months the skin contracts and the tissue thickens, so the breast sits slightly higher and looks fuller. The dashed line shows the early outline. An illustration: every woman heals differently.

Most women end up with breasts that are smaller than they were with implants, of course, and a different shape. But they are rarely the empty socks they were bracing for. The result is usually a pleasant surprise. I’ve also written about what happens if implants aren’t replaced, for women still deciding whether to remove them.

The breast keeps changing shape for three to six months, as swelling settles and the skin contracts. That’s when you see the result, and it’s the earliest point at which it makes sense to decide whether anything else should be done.

Less Is More

Because of that, my approach to implant removal in most cases is simple. Remove the implants. Remove any scar tissue or foreign material that is causing a problem. And call it a day.

I do sometimes perform a lift or fat grafting at the same operation. But in the majority of cases I don’t recommend it. Once the breasts have healed, most women don’t end up needing or wanting either one. And in the cases where they do, the results are usually better when it’s done as a second stage.

Why I Usually Don’t Add a Lift

It’s easy to sell a lift at the time of implant removal. The patient is already picturing those two hanging bags of skin, and suggesting a lift “while we’re in there” sounds sensible and convenient.

The truth is that it’s rarely needed. The breasts usually tighten, and the skin and tissue thicken as they heal. I’ve had this discussion with hundreds of women, and very few of them have ended up getting a lift or needing one.

Even when a woman does turn out to be in that minority, it’s still better to do the lift afterward. A lift is about putting the nipple and the breast where they belong. At the time of removal, nobody knows where that is, because the breast is about to change shape for months. Once everything has healed and tightened, we know where the nipples naturally want to sit, and the lift can be measured precisely and done more accurately. Done at the same time as the removal, a lift is partly a guess. The only real argument for it is convenience.

A lift also means scars, one around the areola and usually one running down from it. I’d rather a woman only accept those scars if she actually needs them. I’ve written more about that trade-off in Breast Lift or Implants?

Why Fat Grafting at the Same Time Rarely Helps

Fat grafting sounds like the perfect companion to implant removal: take a little fat from somewhere you don’t want it and put back some of the volume the implant provided. In practice, at the time of removal, it rarely works the way people hope.

The reason is how fat grafts survive. Transferred fat has no blood supply of its own. It lives only if it picks one up from the tissue around it, and quickly. So you can’t simply put a blob of fat into the empty pocket where the implant was. It would die. Fat has to be placed as tiny droplets spread throughout healthy tissue, so that each droplet is close to blood vessels.

After years under an implant, the breast tissue is often stretched very thin. In some women it’s about as thick as a few sheets of paper. There’s simply nowhere to put a meaningful amount of fat. What can be injected is so little that it makes no real difference, and in most of those cases fat grafting at the same time is close to a sham.

Two other things argue for waiting. First, many women who have implants removed don’t have much fat to spare, so it’s a precious resource and worth using well. Second, even when the tissue is thicker, it usually makes more sense to let the breast heal, see its shape, and then use the fat strategically where it will shape the breast best. At the time of removal you’re guessing where it should go.

Fat grafting has its place. If a woman wants more volume once she has healed, it can be a good option, typically adding about a half to one cup size per session.

What Happens to the Capsule

Every implant is surrounded by a layer of scar tissue the body forms around it, called the capsule. How much of it comes out depends on its condition. If the capsule is thin and healthy, it often doesn’t need to be removed. If it’s thickened or calcified from a bad capsular contracture, it isn’t healthy tissue, and all or almost all of it should come out. The same goes for foreign material, such as old surgical mesh, when it’s causing a problem and can be removed safely.

Some women ask for an en bloc capsulectomy, which removes the implant and the whole capsule together in one piece without opening it. I offer it on request. But for most women it adds nothing, it requires a longer incision, and it isn’t always possible. It became popular several years ago, during the concern about breast implant illness. I’m happy to discuss whether it makes sense for you at your consultation.

Recovery

Recovery from implant removal is usually easier than the original augmentation. Most women return to desk work within 4 to 5 days and to exercise at about three weeks, starting light and building up. Discomfort is usually mild, and non-narcotic medication is almost always enough.

You wear a supportive surgical bra, not a tight binder. Wrapping the chest tightly pushes the breasts around in unpredictable ways and doesn’t help the skin tighten. If a drain is needed after a more extensive capsule removal, it usually comes out within the first week or two.

If You Do Want More Later

For the minority of women who, once they’ve healed, want a little more lift or a little more volume, the options are all still there: a lift, fat grafting, or new implants. I reassess at three to six months, when the breast has settled, and at that point we can measure exactly what’s needed and plan for it. The results are usually better for having waited.

Most women never come back for that second stage. Not because they’ve settled for something, but because they look in the mirror and find they like what they see.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will my breasts look flat after implant removal?

They will look deflated at first. Over the following weeks and months the skin tightens and the breast tissue thickens, and in almost every case the result ends up looking significantly better than the patient expected.

Do I need a breast lift after implant removal?

Most women don’t. Once the breasts have healed, very few end up needing or wanting a lift. For those who do, the lift is usually more accurate after healing, when it is clear where the nipples naturally sit.

Can I have a lift or fat grafting at the same time as implant removal?

Yes, and I sometimes do. But in most cases I don’t recommend it, because most women don’t need either once they heal, and when they do, the results are usually better as a second stage.

How long does it take to see the final result after implant removal?

About three to six months. The breasts keep changing shape as swelling settles and the skin contracts, so any decision about a lift or fat grafting waits until then.

Does the whole capsule need to come out with the implant?

Not usually. Scar tissue that is causing a problem, such as a thick or calcified capsule, is removed. Removing the implant and capsule together in one piece (en bloc) is available on request, but for most women it adds nothing and requires a longer incision.

How long is recovery from breast implant removal?

Most women return to desk work in 4 to 5 days and to exercise at about three weeks, starting light and building up. Discomfort is usually mild.

Related Procedures

Breast Implant Removal · Breast Implant Revision · Breast Lift

Thinking about having your implants removed? Dr. Schwartz will tell you honestly what to expect, and whether you’re likely to need anything more.

Back to Journal

← All Articles