Breast Lift or Implants: Do You Really Need Both?

"Do I need a lift, or will implants be enough?" is one of the most common questions in a breast consultation. The honest answer is that it depends on where you're starting from, and that the decision doesn't always have to be made all at once.

What Sagging Actually Is

Surgeons judge sagging (ptosis) by where the nipple sits relative to the crease under the breast. When the nipple is well above the crease, there's no sagging. When it comes level with the crease, the sagging is mild. When it falls below the crease and points down, the sagging is advanced.

That scale is one of the main guides to whether a lift is needed. The further the nipple has dropped, the less an implant alone can do.

“My Implants Dropped.” Usually They Didn’t.

Many women with implants come in convinced the implants have slipped. In most cases the implant hasn't moved. It still sits right on the crease where it was placed. What has changed is the breast. After weight loss, pregnancy, breastfeeding or simply time, the breast tissue slides down in front of the implant.

There are two ways to fix that. One is a breast lift, which moves the breast back up over the implant. The other is to change the implant, because the implant that suited your breast fifteen years ago may not suit the breast you have today.

How the Right Implant Can Do a Lift’s Job

Much of what makes a breast look lifted is balance. When most of the breast's fullness sits above the nipple, the nipple looks low and the breast looks like it has sagged. When the fullness is closer to evenly split above and below the nipple, the nipple looks centered and the breast looks perky.

An implant can shift that balance in three ways.

Projection, Not Height

"High profile" implants are poorly named. They don't sit higher on the chest. They project farther forward. That forward push carries the breast and nipple out and up, which is why a higher-projection implant can make a breast look lifted without moving the nipple surgically.

Not Too High

It's tempting to want as much fullness at the top as possible. But if the implant sits too high, it makes the breast below it look lower by comparison. Sometimes the better move is to bring the top of the breast down slightly so the whole breast looks balanced.

A Gel That Holds Its Shape

Today's cohesive silicone gels come in different firmness levels. A firmer gel holds its shape when you stand instead of settling to the bottom, which helps keep fullness in the upper breast.

Choosing the Shape You Want

Picture the line from the top of the breast down to the nipple. It can be sunken, straight, gently full, or bulging. Most women ask for a straight or gently full line, which looks natural and perky. A sharply bulging upper breast is the look most people recognize instantly as implants. Some women want it, but it's not what Dr. Schwartz recommends for most.

Your goal photos are the best guide here. Dr. Schwartz reviews them with you, then confirms the final implant during surgery using sterile test implants, rather than guessing the size in advance. More on that in How to Choose the Right Breast Implant Size.

When a Lift Is the Right Call

A breast lift is the most direct fix for a breast that has truly dropped, and it does the job very well. Its trade-off is scarring: usually a scar around the areola and one running down to the crease. On many skin types those scars fade to fine lines, but they are permanent. Read more in Breast Lift Scars: What They Look Like and How They Heal, and about the weeks after surgery in Breast Lift Recovery: What to Expect While You Heal.

For women with advanced sagging, combining the lift and implants in one operation is often the best plan.

Why Waiting Can Be the Smarter Choice

In borderline cases, Dr. Schwartz often recommends doing the implants first and deciding on the lift later. There are three reasons.

1. You may not need it. With the right implant, many women look at the healed result and decide they're happy without a lift. That means no lift scars and no lift cost.
2. You decide with full information. If you do want the lift later, you're choosing it after seeing exactly what the implants achieved. Women who make the decision that way rarely second-guess their scars. When a questionable lift is done up front, it's natural to wonder later whether the scars were necessary.
3. Some combinations are riskier. Dr. Schwartz won't perform a lift on anyone who currently smokes. For anyone with more than a very remote smoking history, he typically recommends doing the augmentation and the lift as separate operations, because combining them raises the risk to the nipple's blood supply. Very large implants are another reason to stage them. A big implant stretches the breast while a lift tightens it, and working against each other raises the risk of healing problems and wider scars.

And if a lift does turn out to be needed, it's a smaller second step. Some minor lifts along the crease under the breast can be done under local anesthesia.

The Advice You’d Give Someone You Love

Doing a lift in every borderline case is easier for a surgeon. It's not always better for the patient. At Edition, the plan is the one Dr. Schwartz would recommend to a loved one: get the result you want with the fewest scars it takes, and keep the bigger step in reserve until you know you need it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can implants lift sagging breasts without a breast lift?

Sometimes. With mild to moderate sagging, an implant chosen for its projection and shape can rebalance the breast so the nipple looks centered and the breast looks lifted. With more advanced sagging, a lift is the only way to move the nipple and tighten the skin.

My implants feel like they've dropped. Do I need a lift?

Often the implant hasn't moved at all. The breast tissue has slid down in front of it with time, weight change or pregnancy. Replacing the implant with one that suits the breast you have now can sometimes fix this without a lift.

Why not just do the lift and implants at the same time?

For many women that is the right plan. In borderline cases, doing the implants first lets you see what they achieve before you decide whether the lift's scars are worth it. Dr. Schwartz won't perform a lift on anyone who currently smokes, and for anyone with more than a very remote smoking history he typically recommends staging the augmentation and the lift. Very large implants are another reason he might recommend staging the two procedures.

If I need a lift later, is that a big deal?

Usually not. A lift after an augmentation is a smaller, separate operation, and some minor lifts along the crease under the breast can even be done under local anesthesia.

If you’re weighing a lift, implants or both, a consultation is the best way to find out where you're starting from and what each path can realistically achieve.

Every surgery carries risks, and results vary from person to person. Your surgeon should explain both before you decide.

Back to Journal

← All Articles